top of page

Metacognition: Seven Questions Worth Asking

Writer: Tim Bower
Tim Bower
3 hours ago
2 min read
A magnifying glass rests on academic research papers about metacognition, self-regulated learning, and assessment. Books and a coffee mug sit nearby on a sunlit wooden desk. The Metacognitive Moves™ logo appears in the upper-right corner.

Metacognition seems to be everywhere these days, and like many of you, I’m trying my best to keep up with developments in the field. The sheer volume of material I come across seems to be growing rapidly.


My curiosity and my work as an applied sociologist have led me to examine a wide range of ideas and research. Along the way, I’ve watched established concepts and constructs become stretched well beyond their theoretical and empirical foundations. I’ve seen this happen with empowerment, burnout, and emotional intelligence, with distinctions between concepts blurred and new terminology introduced for things already understood and well defined.


So, when I encounter something about metacognition, I want to understand whether it’s grounded in relevant theoretical and empirical research or represents little more than an oversimplification, misinterpretation, or simply a marketing claim.


I believe we make the most progress when we develop a shared understanding of what we’re talking about, even as that understanding continues to evolve. That’s why I’m sharing some of the questions I find myself asking as I try to make sense of what’s being presented.


  1. What does the author mean by metacognition? Is there a clear definition, or does the author rely on shorthand such as “thinking about thinking”?


  2. Does the author distinguish metacognition from reflection, self-awareness, awareness of thoughts, self-talk, cognitive reframing, and other psychological activities?


  3. Does the author rely primarily on early understandings and descriptions of metacognition, such as Plan, Monitor, Evaluate, or does their explanation reflect the theoretical and empirical developments of the past several decades?


  4. Does the author introduce new terminology for activities or phenomena already understood within metacognition or other established psychological concepts, particularly terms that function as branding? Here are some of the terms I’ve come across: Thought Literacy™, Meta-Thinking, Metacognitive Mastery, and Emotional Metacognition.


  5. Does the author make exaggerated or scientifically questionable claims about metacognition? For example, does the author describe metacognition as:

    • A superpower or extraordinary human ability?

    • The highest form of intelligence?

    • An executive function?


  6. How is metacognition, or any change in it, measured?


  7. Having considered these questions, what do I need to understand better about metacognition before deciding whether to accept, apply, recommend, or invest in what is being offered?


What questions would you add? I’d love to hear your thoughts and continue the discussion.


If you're interested in exploring metacognition and how to make metacognitive moves, I invite you to join us at B Optimal.

bottom of page